volume | PIER Journals

Abstract

Recently, consumer drones have encroached upon airports and pose a potential threat to aviation safety. Radar is an effective remote sensing tool to detect and track flying drones. Radar echoes from flying birds are assumed to be clutters when a radar is detecting drones. Yet, few studies have reported how radar echoes from flying birds interfere with the detection of drones,how similar radar cross section (RCS) and flight feature of birds and drones are,and why the flying birds cause trouble when radar identifies signals from the drone. In this study, we collected 3900×256 of Ku-band radar echoes of flying birds and consumer drones. The targets consist of a pigeon, a crane, waterfowl, and a DJI Phantom 3 Vision drone. We compared the maximum detectable range of birds and drones, the time series and the Doppler spectrum of radar echoes from the birds and the drone, considering oncoming and outgoing radar data with respect to radar location. The statistical results indicate that flying birds have similar RCS, same velocity range, similar signal fluctuation, and approximate signal amplitude. Our results of radar automatic target recognition (ATR) illuminate that the identification probability of airborne drones will be lower due to the interference of the radar signal by flying birds. Above all, these facts confirm that flying birds are the main cause of interference when a radar is detecting and identifying airborne drones.

1. Gregory, T. S., Z. T. Tse, and D. Lewis, "Drones: Balancing risk and potential," Science, Vol. 347, No. 6228, 1323, 2015.

2. Song, Y., B. Horton, and J. Bayandor, "Investigation of UAS ingestion into high-bypass engines, Part I: Bird vs. drone," 58th AIAA/ASCE/AHS/ASC Structures, Structural Dynamics, and Materials Conference, American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics, Reston, Virginia, 2017.

3. Schroeder, K., Y. Song, B. Horton, and J. Bayandor, "Investigation of UAS ingestion into high-bypass engines, Part II: Parametric drone study," 58th AIAA/ASCE/AHS/ASC Structures, Structural Dynamics, and Materials Conference, American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics, Reston, Virginia, 2017.

4. Gettinger, D. and A. Holland Michel, "Drone sightings and close encountes: An analysis,", Center for the Study of the Drone at Bard College, 2015.

5. Nohara, T. J., R. C. Beason, and P. Weber, "Using radar cross-section to enhance situational awareness tools for airport avian radars," Human-Wildlife Interact., Vol. 5, No. 2, 2011.

6. Jahangir, M., C. J. Baker, and G. A. B. T.-R. C. Oswald, "Doppler characteristics of micro-drones with L-Band multibeam staring radar," IEEE Radar Conference, 1052-1057, 2017.

7. Troxel, S., B. Echels, W. Pughe, and M. Weber, "Progress report on development of a terminal area bird detection and monitoring system using the ASR-9," Bird Strike Comm., 2002.

8. Molchanov, P., K. Egiazarian, J. Astola, et al. "Classification of small UAVs and birds by micro-Doppler signatures," European Radar Conference, 435-444, 2013.

9. Torvik, B., K. E. Olsen, and H. Griffiths, "Classification of birds and UAVs based on radar polarimetry," IEEE Geosci. Remote Sens. Lett., Vol. 13, No. 9, 1305-1309, 2016.

10. Dolbeer, R., S. E. Wright, J. R. Weller, A. L. Anderson, and M. J. Beiger, "Wildlife strikes to civil aircraft in the United States, 1990-2014," Bird Strikes, 2015.

11. Fox, A. D. and P. D. L. Beasley, "David Lack and the birth of radar ornithology," Arch. Nat. Hist., Vol. 37, No. 2, 325-332, 2010.

12. Gauthreaux, S., "Radar ornithology and biological conservation," Auk, Vol. 120, 266-277, 2009.

13. Moon, J. R., "Effects of birds on radar tracking systems," IET Conference Publication, Vol. 490, 300-304, 2002.

14. Harman, S., "A comparison of staring radars with scanning radars for UAV detection: Introducing the Alarm^TM staring radar," IEEER Adar Conference, 2015.

15. Gustavsson, M., A. Andersson, T. Johansson, et al. "Micro-Doppler extraction of a small UAV in a non-line-of-sight urban scenario," Radar Sensor Technology XXI, International Society for Optics and Photonics, 2017.

16. Harman, S., "Characteristics of the radar signature of multi-rotor UAVs," IEEE Radar Conference, 2016.

17. Stein, K. U., et al. "Numerical RCS and micro-Doppler analysis of a consumer UAV," SPIE Proceedings [SPIE SPIE Security + Defence - Edinburgh, United Kingdom (Monday, September 26, 2016)] Target and Background Signatures II, 2016.

18. Ren, J. and X. Jiang, "Regularized 2-D complex-log spectral analysis and subspace reliability analysis of micro-Doppler signature for UAV detection," Pattern Recognit., 2017.

19. Ritchie, M. A., F. Fioranelli, H. Griffiths, et al. "Monostatic and bistatic radar measurements of birds and micro-drone," IEEE Radar Conference, 2016.

20. Manfred, B., A. F. Jacob, and S. Lorenz-Peter, "Classification of small UAVs and birds by micro-Doppler signatures," Int. J. Microw. Wirel. Technol., Vol. 6, No. 3-4, 435-444, 2014.

21. Gauthreaux, S. A., "Radar ornithology and biological conservation," Auk, Vol. 120, No. 2, 266-277, 2003.

22. Skolnik, M., Radar Handbook, McGraw-Hill Education, 2008.

23. Tait, P., Introduction to Radar Target Recognition, Institution of Electrical Engineers, 2005.

24. U. S. D. of Transportation and U. S. F. A. Administration "Airport Avian Radar Systems - Advisory Circular 150/5220-25,", 2010.

25. Melnikov, V. M., R. R. Lee, and N. J. Langlieb, "Resonance effects within S-band in echoes from birds," IEEE Geosci. Remote Sens. Lett., Vol. 9, No. 3, 413-416, 2012.

26. Bruderer, B., D. Peter, A. Boldt, and F. Liechti, "Wing-beat characteristics of birds recorded with tracking radar and cine camera," Ibis (Lond. 1859), Vol. 152, No. 2, 272-291, 2010.

27. Zaugg, S., G. Saporta, E. van Loon, H. Schmaljohann, and F. Liechti, "Automatic identification of bird targets with radar via patterns produced by wing flapping," J. R. Soc. Interface, Vol. 5, No. 26, 1041-1053, 2008.

28. Bonham, L. L. and L. V. Blake, "Radar echoes from birds and insects," Sci. Mon., Vol. 82, No. 4, 204-209, 1956.

29. Blacksmith, Jr., P. and R. B. Mack, "On measuring the radar cross sections of ducks and chickens," Proc. IEEE, Vol. 53, No. 8, 1125, 1965.

30. Konrad, T. G., J. J. Hicks, and E. B. Dobson, "Radar characteristics of birds in flight. Radar tracking of known single birds indicates a characteristic radar signature," Science, Vol. 159, No. 3812, 274-280, 1968.

31. Vaughn, C. R., "Birds and insects as radar targets: A review," Proc. IEEE, Vol. 73, No. 2, 205-227, 1985.

32. O'Neal, B. J., J. D. Stafford, and R. P. Larkin, "Waterfowl on weather radar: Applying ground-truth to classify and quantify bird movements," J. F. Ornithol., Vol. 81, No. 1, 71-82, 2010.

33. Torvik, B., K. E. Olsen, and H. Griffiths, "K-band radar signature analysis of a flying mallard duck," 14th International Radar Symposium (IRS), Vol. 2, 584-591, 2013.

34. Torvik, B., K. E. Olsen, and H. D. Griffiths, "X-band measurements of radar signatures of large sea birds," International Radar Conference, 1-6, 2014.

35. Urmy, S. S. and J. D. Warren, "Quantitative ornithology with a commercial marine radar: Standard-target calibration, target detection and tracking, and measurement of echoes from individuals and flocks," Methods Ecol. Evol., Vol. 8, 2016.

36. Van Doren, B. M. and K. G. Horton, "A continental system for forecasting bird migration," Science, Vol. 361, No. 6407, 1115-1118, 2018.

37. Ritchie, M., F. Fioranelli, H. Griffiths, and B. B. T.-R. C. Torvik, "Micro-drone RCS analysis," Radar Conference IEEE, 452-456, 2016.

38. Pieraccini, M., L. Miccinesi, and N. Rojhani, "RCS measurements and ISAR images of small UAVs," IEEE Aerosp. Electron. Syst. Mag., Vol. 32, No. 9, 28-32, 2017.

39. Farlik, J., M. Kratky, J. Casar, and V. B. T.-I. C, "Radar cross section and detection of small unmanned aerial vehicles," IEEE International Conference on Mechatronics-Mechatronika, 452-456, 2017.

40. Nakamura, R. and H. Hadama, "Characteristics of ultra-wideband radar echoes from a drone," IEICE Commun. Express, Vol. 6, 2017.

41. Harmanny, R. I. A., J. J. M. De Wit, and G. Prémel Cabic, "Radar micro-Doppler feature extraction using the spectrogram and the cepstrogram," Euma, 165-168, 2014.

42. Mohajerin, N., J. Histon, R. Dizaji, and S. L. B. T.-R. C. Waslander, "Feature extraction and radar track classification for detecting UAVs in civillian airspace," IEEE Radar Conference, 674-679, 2014.

43. Li, C. and H. Ling, "An investigation on the radar signatures of small consumer drones," IEEE Antennas Wirel. Propag. Lett., Vol. 16, 649-652, 2017.

Mr. Jiangkun Gong

Dr. Jun Yan

Dr. Deren Li

Dr. Deyong Kong

Dr. Huiping Hu